Key Thinker 1: Simone de Beauvoir:
Known as the
first existential feminist.
Externalism
set the freedom of the individual against the constrictions placed
on him/her by the moral and religious world by opposing them their
own will upon life.
Also
developed the idea of women as Other. The idea was that men had
characterised women as different, but different in a way of men’s
choosing not the choice of women themselves
She rejected
the notion that girls are born without any nurturing instinct
rather, she asserts that they learn it from their parents and from
their schooling. Their freedom to choose their own way of life is
removed almost from birth. The position they play in society has
been determined by men.
Her solution
to the plight of women was for women to be granted as the
opportunity to make as many choices as men and to be able to escape
marriage. They must seek sexual liberation and freedom from the
nuclear family
“One is
not born but rather becomes a woman. No biological, psychological or
economic fate determines the figure that the human female presents
in society; it is civilisation that produces this creature.”
Key
Thinker 2: bell hooks:
A radical
black American feminist, best known for her work in
intersectionality.
She says
that society is completely disfigured by inequality in general.
Diverse groups, not just women suffer from inequality.
She thinks
that for women to have equality, all of society must have equality.
hook
criticises many feminists for not recognising this reality. They
concentrate too much on women. She thinks that for black women to
achieve equality, black people must gain equality first. This is
true of many groups such as gay men.
Men have a
valid role to play because they can enter the struggle against
inequality of all groups.
hooks
thought that women had been taught by the patriarchy to hate
themselves. “…patriarchal thinking to see ourselves as always
and only in competition with one another in patriarchal approval”
Two elements
hooks had: A more equal society so the disadvantages women face can
be reduced and eliminated & men must understand the patriarchy
that they are imposing whilst women must break free of the
preconceptions about themselves.
She belongs
mainly to the contemporary branch of the movement known as
post-modern feminism as she is attempting to break the movement free
of its traditional perspective and to accept modern realities.
Key
Thinker 3: Sheila Rowbotham:
A leading
English socialist feminist, who thought that Marxists took a narrow
view of the oppression of women by confining themselves to analysing
the role of women in industrial capitalism.
She wrote
one of the best-known statements in feminist literature when she
said: “Men will often admit other women are oppressed but not you”
– this implied that men cannot really understand the nature of
oppression they are imposing on women.
Rowbotham
sees the best hope for women lies in a socialist future; under
capitalism, there is little hope that women will ever be able to
escape from patriarchal society. She points out that the greatest
advances for women have taken place after socialist revolutions. The
capitalist society in the 1980s appeared to offer widening
opportunities for women but it did not offer ultimate liberation and
little progress was made. Women remained a cheap source of labour.
She is a
Marxist and critic of Marxism. The inferior position of women is
seen by Marxists as economically determined with which she agrees
but she adds that this is too narrow. Women are oppressed in the
home and the wider culture. She thinks women must be freed from
oppression from within the home too.
She thinks
that it is much of a task for men to end the oppression than for
women. Women cannot do It in their home, they need men to become
willing to relinquish their dominant position by seeing patriarchy
for what it is really for.
Key
Thinker 4: Charlotte Perkins Gilman:
Expressed
her vision of early feminism in both fictional works and scholarly
writings.
Gilman set
up an attack on those who suggested that Darwin’s theories could
be used to justify male domination of society
Survival of
the fittest suggested that it was biologically inevitable that men
should be the dominant sex because they were more suited to be
competitive in nature and being stronger. Gilman argued that this
was not the case because of the nature of economic activity had
changed so much.
She thought
that there were no reason women could not play an equal part in
society, she asserted that women had the equal brain power to men
and this justified their equality in modern society.
Women could
be liberated is a lay inequality of opportunity and therefore a full
place in the world of employment. She understood that girls are
socialised from an early age at home or at school to take on the
role of motherhood and homemaking rather than thinking of a wider
range and career in the economic world outside the home. Their homes
in the home are culturally determined – not biologically.
She wrote
“the labour of women in the house certainly enables men to produce
more wealth than they could otherwise, and in this way, women are
economic factors in society. But so are horses”
She was
concerned that child-rearing and housework amounted to domestic
slavery. She campaigned for the destruction of the traditional
nuclear family and its replacement by forms of communal living
whereby child rearing and housework would be shared both among women
and men thus freeing women for a wider role in society.
Key
Thinker 5: Kate Millett:
An American
radical feminist. She was first active in the National Organisation
for Women but she quickly moved towards a more radical form of
politics.
She sees the
dominance of men in terms of both sexism – an entrenched belief in
male superiority and heterosexualism – the idea that heterosexual
relationships are superior to gay relationships.
Her main
contention in Sexual Politics was that it is necessary for women to
find sexual liberation first if they are to achieve liberation in
general life. Heterosexual relationships are political in a
patriarchal society because they involve men exercising power over
women.
She also
analysed women’s place in society. She thought that when one group
oppresses another, the result is political in nature and the
solution must be the liberation of the oppressed group.
Some of her
ideas chime with ideas of socialist ideas with working-class women
“the toil of working-class women is more readily accepted as
“need”, if not always by the working class itself. It serves the
purpose of making cheap labour in factory and low-grade service…
It fails to threaten patriarchy financially or psychologically.”
She also
implied in the above quotations that Millett criticised parts of the
feminist movement for being concerned largely with problems relating
to middle-class women.
Summary Of Key Thinkers:
|
|
Human Nature:
|
The State:
|
Society:
|
The Economy:
|
Simone De Beauvoir:
|
Gender differences are created by men in society. They are not
natural
|
The state reinforces a culture that prevents women from expressing
their true freedom and identity
|
De Beauvoir’s existentialism dominated her feminism. Social
constraints prevent individuals, not just women from attaining
self-realisation and true freedom
|
Men’s domination of economic life restricts the life choices
open to women
|
bell hooks:
|
Women, in common with men, have multiple identities and therefore
experience multiple forms of oppression
|
The state is dominated by white males and therefore reflects and
reinforces their dominant position in society
|
Society is full of complex relationships between different
minorities. To resolve social conflict, love between different
minority cultures must be established
|
Women living in poverty have problems that middle-class women do
not face. The liberation of the poor is an economic as well as a
social issue
|
Sheila Rowbotham:
|
Women’s consciousness of the world is created by men
|
The state is the servant of capitalism
|
The nature of society is economically determined. Society reflects
the dominant position of both capitalists and men in general
|
Rowbotham has a Marxist perspective. Women are a low-paid reverse
army of labour
|
Charlotte Perkins Gilman:
|
The biological differences between men and women are irrelevant.
Women can compete equally with men.
|
Gilman had no especially distinctive views on the state.
|
Society has always assigned inferior roles to women. In modern
society, this no longer has any justification
|
The domestic servitude of women allowed men to dominate the
outside economic world.
|
Kate Millett:
|
Women are all capable of freeing themselves from male oppression
by engaging in lesbian relationships
|
The state is merely the agent of patriarchy. It is part of the
problem but not the solution
|
Modern society is completely characterised by patriarchy, which is
all pervasive and infests both the private and public sphere.
|
Millett is a quasi-socialist but this is not fundamental to her
feminism.
|